Context
A nationwide chain of service venues (the fitness industry) with many locations across the country, where social media is the main channel of communication with current and potential customers – promotions, class timetables, local communication specific to each club. Several dozen profiles were run by an external social media agency on a monthly flat fee.
The problem
Several dozen social media profiles and as many Google Maps listings were run by an external team, to which the in-house marketing team had limited administrative access. Changing a class timetable, a promotion or information about a temporary closure meant submitting a request to the agency and waiting for it to be published – even a delay of a few hours in announcing that a club was closed caused dissatisfaction among customers on site.
The result: the channel closest to customers on the ground was also the channel with the slowest response.
Diagnosis – the first 4 weeks
The audit covered all the profiles being run, the agency’s actual response time to requests and the cost of the flat fee compared with market rates for work of comparable scope done in-house.
What we did
- Recruited 2 social media specialists into the in-house structure, taking over full management of all profiles and Google Maps listings
- Took back full administrative access to all accounts – an end to depending on the agency as an intermediary for even the simplest changes
- Introduced a shared content calendar and local communication templates, allowing each club to adapt content quickly without creating it from scratch
- Set an internal response-time standard: operational changes (club closure, timetable change) published within a maximum of 2 hours of being reported
Why local social media needs a local owner
Communication spread across dozens of locations is different in nature from a national campaign – it is operational, not just about image. A fitness club member checking the class timetable or a notice about a temporary closure expects information as current as a text message, not one that follows an agency’s publishing cycle. An external team, however competent, will always add an extra link between an event and its communication.
Results
Metric
Reduction in the cost of running social media (in-house vs agency model)
~78%
Time to publish an operational change
from just over a day to around 2–3 hours
Profiles (X, TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn) and Google Maps listings
+45
ROI from the transformation
Social media (several dozen profiles, external cost of several tens of thousands of PLN a month) → 2 FTEs at market rates
Calculation: annual saving of ~PLN 816,000 a year (c. €190k)
The monthly cost fell from a flat fee of several tens of thousands of PLN to the cost of two full-time roles at market rates – a difference that on its own would cover the annual salary of one more person on the team if the chain wanted to keep growing its number of locations.
Not included: the revenue effect of cutting campaign roll-out time from days to hours. Faster response to seasonal promotions and new treatments probably translated into additional sales, but without data on the opportunities lost under the old model it can’t be calculated reliably – which is why the summary includes only the hard cost saving.
Why it doesn’t end with a one-off takeover of the accounts
Taking the profiles back from the agency solves the problem of access and response time on the day of the takeover – it doesn’t guarantee that a year later, with a chain twice the size, two people will still be enough. The number of locations grows, and with it the number of profiles, listings and day-to-day requests to handle.
An in-house social media team needs the same thing outsourcing needed at the start – a periodic check on whether its size and tools are keeping up with the scale of the chain, before response times start to lengthen for the same reasons that led to the first change.
Key lesson
Not every marketing channel needs the same operating model. A national campaign can live with an agency’s working cycle. Local, operational communication about a specific place on a specific day can’t. Matching the model to the nature of the channel – not the other way round – is what distinguishes well-designed marketing from marketing that is simply outsourced.
