Context
A nationwide chain of beauty salons, developed for years on a regional model – with separate teams in several large cities (including the Tri-City area, Warsaw, Lublin, Wrocław, Chorzów and Olsztyn), each of which built its own local range of services: hair removal, nail styling, massages and beauty treatments. Each region also ran its own independent online presence – six separate websites in total, running on six different platforms.
The problem
The offer comprised around 140 services, created independently by six regional teams, with no single coherent plan, no shared pricing strategy and no one responsible for a bird’s-eye view of the whole portfolio. The same or very similar services existed under different names and at different price points depending on the city, and new items introduced locally were not checked against the other regions’ offer – so they began to overlap with it and compete for the same customer instead of complementing it. Maintaining six separate websites on six different platforms further multiplied the cost and time needed for any change to the offer.
The result: a recognisable brand exposed to reputational risk by a fragmented, internally competing portfolio that was expensive to maintain and unclear both to customers and to the chain itself.
Diagnosis
A full review of the entire portfolio – each of the roughly 140 services assessed individually by category, duration, margin and sales performance in each region, and then compared with market benchmarks. In parallel, we analysed the internal processes responsible for creating and pricing services in each region, and the whole customer booking path.
What we did
- Developed a single scoring system for services, allowing them to be compared with one another regardless of which region created them
- Built consistent price tiers and a single pricing strategy for the whole portfolio, instead of prices set separately by each region
- Categorised and catalogued services by type of treatment and duration, so customers could choose between them knowingly instead of getting lost
- Reduced the portfolio from around 140 to 50 services forming the new MVP – the core of the offer on which further development was built
- Developed an up-selling strategy across service categories and treatment packages
- Once the new framework had stabilised – controlled scaling back up, adding new services to the portfolio based on customer demand signals set against analytics data, not on the instincts of individual regions
Why portfolio cannibalisation costs more than it seems
When several regions create their offer independently of one another, each optimises for its own goal, not for the chain’s portfolio as a whole. At the level of a single decision this rarely looks like a problem – it is only when you put them together that dozens of such independent decisions produce an offer in which services take customers from each other instead of building revenue together.
Reducing the portfolio wasn’t cutting for the sake of cutting. The 50 services that remained were the ones that genuinely differed enough for customers to choose between them knowingly. The rest added no extra value – only extra confusion.
Results
Metric
Pricing structure
Fragmented, set separately by each region -> one consistent pricing strategy
Scaling the portfolio after the reduction
driven by demand data, not by the regions’ instincts
Cutting almost two-thirds of the portfolio sounds drastic, but none of the 50 remaining services lost sales compared with its previous volume – the only services removed were those that cannibalised the sales of others without generating unique value of their own.
On its own this stage did not yet generate revenue – its business value only became clear at the next stage. A tidy, consistent portfolio of 50 services was a precondition for designing a new, shared sales system which in its first year generated well over PLN 10 million (more than €2.3m) in revenue and ~1,200% ROI on the investment in building it (described in a separate case study). Without first cutting from 140 to 50 services, the shop would not have had a coherent structure around which to design one clear booking path – 140 competing services scattered across six regional websites could not have been sensibly catalogued in one place.
Why a service portfolio needs one owner, not several
Distributed responsibility for a service portfolio works well as long as the number of services and regions is small. Above a certain scale – and six independent regions with 140 services are well above that line – the absence of one person looking at the whole from above inevitably leads to services competing with each other, because no one has the full picture of how one region’s decision affects another’s results.
Without regular review the same mechanism is predictable: new services added by successive regions, each rational on its own, will start to overlap again if no one keeps an eye on the portfolio as a whole on an ongoing basis.
Key lesson
A service portfolio rarely suffers because of individual weak services – it suffers from the lack of someone responsible for how those services work together across regions. Reducing the number of services was only the consequence of a deeper change: the move from the scattered good intentions of six regions to one coherent portfolio strategy.
